Introduction
Gattaca isn’t just another sleek slice of 90s science fiction—it’s a mirror held up to the human obsession with perfection. Eve and I open this episode by stepping into a world where your DNA is your destiny, and where the so-called “valid” get the stars while the “in-valids” are sentenced to the mop. Sounds futuristic, but nearly three decades later, it’s chillingly familiar.
The movie dares us to wrestle with questions that aren’t fiction anymore: What makes a life valuable? Can technology really erase our flaws, or is the relentless attempt to “fix” human crookedness just a way of ignoring the deeper truth of why we’re bent in the first place?
We’re diving into big themes—discrimination enforced at the genetic level, the fragile myth of human control, the dignity of life from conception, and the danger of chasing authenticity without truth. If that sounds heavy, good. Stick with us. Gattaca’s story exposes more about our own world than we’d like to admit.
Introduction: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca sets the stage for questions of perfection, discrimination, and dignity. This intro teases themes of human attempts to straighten what only God can set right.
Opening Thoughts
Eve started this episode with a confession—Gattaca still gives her chills. She’s seen it several times, and even knowing the ending, she gets swept up in Vincent’s desperate climb to the stars. The slow pacing that might frustrate modern audiences actually works for her, because it lets the tension simmer. Nearly three decades old, the film still feels fresh, and as Eve pointed out, what was once speculative science is edging closer to our reality.
I had a very different reaction. To be honest, Vincent made me uncomfortable from the start. If I’m going to invest in a story, I need someone I can sympathize with, and I found him unlikable. That doesn’t mean I didn’t enjoy the movie—I just latched onto other things. The retro-futurist set design with its art-deco minimalism fascinated me. I loved how the style matched the story’s themes of sterile perfection. And hey, some of my favorite actors pop up in small roles—Alan Arkin, Tony Shaloub, Ernest Borgnine. That helped me stay engaged.
One moment even made me laugh out loud. Shaloub’s character is named “German,” and the closed captions apparently decided that meant his dialogue was in German. So every time he spoke, it came up as, “In German: …” For a movie this heavy, that little glitch was priceless.
But underneath the polish, I couldn’t shake the darker undercurrents. The film never even hints at improved contraception. If everyone’s manipulating DNA, what happens to all the “unplanned” pregnancies? The implication seems to be abortion on a massive scale. And then there’s the ending, where a major character commits suicide, framed almost as a noble sacrifice once his usefulness is gone. Those unspoken dystopian notes weighed on me more than the overt conflict.
This is where Eve’s book helps frame what’s happening. Underneath the story are two key worldview layers. First, Authority: who gets to decide what perfection is? In Gattaca, it’s scientists in lab coats, dictating destiny by genetic readouts. Scripture tells us truth rests in God’s authority, not man’s consensus. Second, Presuppositions: the movie assumes that if we tinker with the blueprint long enough, we can straighten out humanity’s crookedness. But the Bible reminds us that sin—not faulty DNA—is the real problem.
So our opening reactions set the stage: Eve felt the story’s pull, I felt the unease, and both of us came face-to-face with a film that forces big questions. And those questions are where the real conversation begins.
Opening Thoughts: Screen Reader Summary
Eve was drawn into Gattaca’s suspense, while I struggled with Vincent but admired the film’s design and acting. Together, we noted the darker implications—abortion, suicide, and misplaced authority in science—and framed them through Authority and Presuppositions.
The Impossible Standard of Perfection in Gattaca
One of the central tensions in Gattaca is this so-called promise of perfection. In the film, geneticists can map out every possible trait before conception. Parents are told they can choose health, intelligence, and even appearance if they’re willing to sort through enough embryos. The story doesn’t hide the darker implication—that only the “best” embryos get implanted. The rest are discarded as not good enough. What sounded like science fiction in 1997 is now unsettlingly close to reality. Today, embryo screening and designer-baby services are not just theory but practice (see Wall Street Journal report).
For Vincent, born the old-fashioned way, the contrast is sharp. His younger brother Anton is engineered to be stronger, faster, and healthier. Vincent becomes the black sheep in his own family, not because he lacked love, but because society treated him as sickly and disposable. Gattaca doesn’t mince words—if you aren’t genetically optimized, you’re “invalid.”
Eugene, or Jerome as Vincent knows him, provides the counterpoint. He had flawless genetics. Every box checked, every trait ideal. And yet, a single accident left him disabled, no longer able to live up to the promise of his perfect profile. His worth in this society collapsed with his body. To survive, he sold his genetic identity to Vincent—ironically proving that perfection was always an illusion. We’ve talked before about science promising perfection, like in our review of Captain America: The First Avenger.
Gattaca keeps crashing into its own limits. Engineering can raise the odds, but it never erases risk. Eugene’s accident, Irene’s disqualification, and Vincent’s improbable triumph all say the same thing: no profile can make a flawless person—or a flawless life.
Then God said, ‘Let us make man in our image, according to our likeness. They will rule the fish of the sea, the birds of the sky, the livestock, the whole earth, and the creatures that crawl on the earth.’ So God created man in his own image; he created him in the image of God; he created them male and female. God blessed them, and God said to them, ‘Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it. Rule the fish of the sea, the birds of the sky, and every creature that crawls on the earth.’ God also said, ‘Look, I have given you every seed-bearing plant on the surface of the entire earth and every tree whose fruit contains seed. This will be food for you, for all the wildlife of the earth, for every bird of the sky, and for every creature that crawls on the earth—everything having the breath of life in it—I have given every green plant for food.’ And it was so. God saw all that he had made, and it was very good indeed. Evening came and then morning: the sixth day. (Genesis 1:26–31)
Humanity began perfect, reflecting God’s image in a perfect creation. But that didn’t last.
Now the serpent was the most cunning of all the wild animals that the Lord God had made. He said to the woman, ‘Did God really say, “You can’t eat from any tree in the garden”?’ The woman said to the serpent, ‘We may eat the fruit from the trees in the garden. But about the fruit of the tree in the middle of the garden, God said, “You must not eat it or touch it, or you will die.”’ ‘No! You will certainly not die,’ the serpent said to the woman. ‘In fact, God knows that when you eat it your eyes will be opened and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.’ The woman saw that the tree was good for food and delightful to look at, and that it was desirable for obtaining wisdom. So she took some of its fruit and ate it; she also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate it. (Genesis 3:1–6)
From that act of disobedience, sin corrupted creation. The problem wasn’t a missing gene; it was rebellion against God.
For the creation was subjected to futility—not willingly, but because of him who subjected it—in the hope that the creation itself will also be set free from the bondage to decay into the glorious freedom of God’s children. For we know that the whole creation has been groaning together with labor pains until now. Not only that, but we ourselves who have the Spirit as the firstfruits—we also groan within ourselves, eagerly waiting for adoption, the redemption of our bodies. (Romans 8:20–23)
Every broken chromosome, every miscarriage, every accident like Eugene’s—all are symptoms of a creation still groaning under curse. That groaning can’t be solved in a laboratory.
So it is with the resurrection of the dead: Sown in corruption, raised in incorruption; sown in dishonor, raised in glory; sown in weakness, raised in power; sown a natural body, raised a spiritual body. If there is a natural body, there is also a spiritual body. (1 Corinthians 15:42–44)
Here is the real promise of perfection—not test tubes or embryo selection, but resurrection. God doesn’t promise us stronger DNA; He promises incorruptible bodies.
Only see this: I have discovered that God made people upright, but they pursued many schemes. (Ecclesiastes 7:29)
That’s what Gattaca captures, often without meaning to. Humanity was made upright, but we chased schemes. The lab technicians promise a fix for crookedness that only Christ can redeem.
Are you so foolish? After beginning by the Spirit, are you now finishing by the flesh? (Galatians 3:3)
Trying to engineer perfection through science is exactly that—finishing in the flesh what can only begin in the Spirit.
So where does this leave us? With Authority and Presuppositions. Gattaca assumes man has authority to define and create perfection. It presupposes that flaws are merely biological and that enough tinkering will set things right. But scripture tells us otherwise. Authority rests with God, who declared creation good, and presuppositions must start with the reality of sin. Without that lens, science promises perfection but can never deliver.
As viewers, this is where we need to pause. The allure of control is powerful. The temptation to scheme our way into an ideal future is as old as Eden. Gattaca puts that counterfeit on the screen and dares us to believe it. But the Christian response is to remember: perfection was lost in sin, regained only in Christ, and promised fully in resurrection. No genome can match that.
The Impossible Standard of Perfection in Gattaca: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca shows parents picking “perfect” embryos and discarding the rest. The film exposes society’s false hope in science to fix human crookedness. Scripture reminds us that perfection was lost in sin, not genetics, and true restoration comes only in Christ’s resurrection.
Genetic Determinism (or Prejudice) in Gattaca
In Gattaca, your destiny is decided before you take your first breath. Genetic testing sorts people into two categories: the “valid,” who are engineered for strength and intellect, and the “invalid,” who are natural-born and therefore assumed to be defective. From there, the rest of life is predetermined. Invalids are funneled into menial work, while valids are given every opportunity. It’s prejudice not by skin color or social class, but by the very code written into your DNA.
That’s what makes Vincent’s story disruptive. Growing up, he absorbed the message that he would never achieve anything. He was taught to set his sights low, and the system reinforced it every step of the way. Yet when Vincent beats his genetically superior brother Anton in a swim, the illusion cracks. Genetics may set probabilities, but they can’t define identity, character, or perseverance.
The irony is that the system’s prejudice becomes self-fulfilling. If you’re told from birth you’re inferior, you’ll often live down to that expectation. And if you’re told you’re superior, you may coast on that false security. Either way, the stereotype becomes the cage. This prejudice echoes what we saw in X-Men: Apocalypse (Part I, Part II), where genetic differences sparked fear and division.
This is where discernment comes in. Eve’s book talks about stereotypes as shortcuts in storytelling, but in Gattaca they’re elevated into law. Valids are stereotyped as capable and flawless, invalids as weak and unworthy. The Bible dismantles that entire framework.
“Why do you call me good?” Jesus asked him. “No one is good except God alone. (Mark 10:18)
For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God; they are justified freely by his grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus. (Romans 3:23–24)
My brothers and sisters, do not show favoritism as you hold on to the faith in our glorious Lord Jesus Christ. (James 2:1)
There is no Jew or Greek, slave or free, male and female; since you are all one in Christ Jesus. (Galatians 3:28)
In other words, the ground is level at the foot of the cross. No lab result or genetic profile can change that.
Genetic Determinism (or Prejudice) in Gattaca: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca divides people into “valids” and “invalids,” enforcing prejudice at the genetic level. Vincent’s defiance exposes the system’s flaws, while scripture reminds us that all are sinners, all need grace, and all are equal in Christ.
Protagonist Without Heroism
One of the subtle manipulations in Gattaca is how it frames Vincent. The film doesn’t just make him the protagonist—it works hard to make him feel like the hero. We’re meant to cheer as he bends the rules, slips past the scanners, and uses Jerome’s DNA to climb toward the stars. But sympathy for the underdog doesn’t make him admirable.
There’s an important distinction here. A protagonist is simply the character whose story drives the narrative. A hero, by contrast, is a person of noble character whose actions inspire imitation. Vincent fits the first definition perfectly. He is the central figure, the one whose choices propel the story forward. But hero? That’s a harder sell. His path is paved with deception, selfish ambition, and exploitation of Jerome’s identity. That’s not heroism—it’s fraud dressed up with a swell of music. Vincent’s false heroism reminded me of the way deception played into Spider-Man: Far From Home.
This is where Stories, as Eve describes them in her book, matter so much. Stories don’t just entertain; they teach us what to admire, what to desire, what to excuse. Gattaca tells us that authenticity means “proving your worth no matter what rules you break.” That’s secular humanism in a nutshell—self-made identity, self-made salvation. If you can game the system and make it to space, then you’ve achieved your purpose.
But biblical authenticity isn’t about ambition or rebellion. It’s about humility, truth, and service. Vincent’s lies might look noble on screen, but they collapse against scripture.
Do nothing out of selfish ambition or conceit, but in humility consider others as more important than yourselves. Everyone should look not to his own interests, but rather to the interests of others. (Philippians 2:3–4)
The film wants us to believe Vincent is a hero because he defies limits. But biblically, he’s just a man chasing glory at the expense of others. That’s not the kind of story Christians are called to imitate.
Protagonist Without Heroism: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca paints Vincent as a hero, but his path is built on lies and ambition. The film equates defiance with authenticity, while scripture calls us to humility, truth, and service.
Human Value and Dignity in Gattaca
One of the hardest parts of Gattaca to watch is how little value human life holds in its world. “Invalids” are treated as second-class citizens, given menial jobs and looked at as a drain on society. Even before birth, embryos that don’t meet genetic standards are simply discarded. And in the end, Eugene—once prized for his perfect genetics—chooses to end his own life, presented almost as a noble gesture once his usefulness is spent. It’s a chilling picture of dignity defined by utility. We’ve seen this utilitarian view of life before, especially with Thanos in our review of Avengers: Infinity War.
The parallels to our world are not far-fetched. Prenatal testing already gives parents the option to terminate pregnancies when genetic conditions are discovered (ABC report). In vitro fertilization allows not only for discarding embryos but even for sex selection (CCRM IVF resource). Gattaca was speculative fiction in the 90s, but in 2025 its ethical questions sit squarely in the headlines.
Eve’s book talks about Reality—and here, the film’s counterfeit reality reduces life to performance and potential. But the true reality is that life has value because God gives it value. From conception to death, every person bears His image.
I chose you before I formed you in the womb; I set you apart before you were born. I appointed you a prophet to the nations. (Jeremiah 1:5)
For it was you who created my inward parts; you knit me together in my mother’s womb… Your eyes saw me when I was formless; all my days were written in your book and planned before a single one of them began. (Psalm 139:13,16)
For you see, when the sound of your greeting reached my ears, the baby leaped for joy inside me. (Luke 1:44)
These verses leave no doubt—God Himself shapes life in the womb, knows every day before it begins, and acknowledges personhood even before birth. That reality is non-negotiable, no matter how advanced our technology.
So when Gattaca portrays life as expendable, it forces us to confront a lie that our own culture is already believing. True human dignity isn’t defined by genes, usefulness, or potential—it’s defined by the Creator.
Human Value and Dignity in Gattaca: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca devalues human life through discrimination, discarded embryos, and suicide framed as noble. Scripture affirms that God forms life in the womb and grants each person dignity that technology cannot erase.
Conclusion
As we step back from Gattaca, the film feels less like speculative fiction and more like a mirror. Nearly thirty years old, it still speaks to today’s headlines—embryo selection, genetic determinism, questions of human worth. Eve and I came to it from different angles: she felt the tension of Vincent’s struggle, I wrestled with the unease of his deception. But together, we saw how the story presses big questions that Christians cannot ignore.
Through Authority, we asked who gets to define perfection. Through Presuppositions, we saw the assumption that science can fix what sin has broken. Through Stereotypes, we traced how prejudice becomes law. Through Stories, we examined Vincent’s counterfeit heroism. And through Reality, we measured the dignity of life against the Creator’s design. Every lens pointed us back to the same truth: humanity’s problem is not genetic, it’s spiritual—and Christ alone redeems it.
In the end, Gattaca challenges us not just to critique a movie but to consider the narratives shaping our culture. Do we quietly accept the lie that worth comes from ability, usefulness, or flawless DNA? Or do we stand on the reality that every human life bears God’s image? The film may offer no hope beyond human achievement, but the gospel offers incorruptible life through Christ’s resurrection. That’s the story worth living—and the one worth passing on.
Conclusion: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca raises questions about perfection, prejudice, and dignity. Our conclusion: humanity’s problem is spiritual, not genetic, and true hope rests only in Christ’s redemption.
Global Screen Reader Summary
In this episode, we review Gattaca through a Christian worldview. We explore themes of perfection, prejudice, counterfeit heroism, and the dignity of life, using scripture and discernment principles from Eve Franklin’s Are You Just Watching? handbook. Our conclusion: science cannot fix humanity’s brokenness—only Christ offers true redemption and hope.
Please support the podcast!
Are You Just Watching? is listener supported. Special thanks to our current patrons: Isaias Santillano, Craig Hardee, Stephen Brown II, and David Lefton, for their generous support. We can't continue to share critical thinking for the entertained Christian without your financial help, so please head on over to our Patreon page and become one of our supporting patrons!
Share your feedback!
What did you think of Gattaca? We would like to know, even if just your reactions to the trailer or the topics we shared in this episode. Or what general critical-thinking and entertainment thoughts or questions do you have? Would you like to suggest a movie or TV show for us to give a Christian movie review with critical thinking?
Please connect with us
Gattaca isn’t just another sleek slice of 90s science fiction—it’s a mirror held up to the human obsession with perfection. Eve and I open this episode by stepping into a world where your DNA is your destiny, and where the so-called “valid” get the stars while the “in-valids” are sentenced to the mop. Sounds futuristic, but nearly three decades later, it’s chillingly familiar.
The movie dares us to wrestle with questions that aren’t fiction anymore: What makes a life valuable? Can technology really erase our flaws, or is the relentless attempt to “fix” human crookedness just a way of ignoring the deeper truth of why we’re bent in the first place?
We’re diving into big themes—discrimination enforced at the genetic level, the fragile myth of human control, the dignity of life from conception, and the danger of chasing authenticity without truth. If that sounds heavy, good. Stick with us. Gattaca’s story exposes more about our own world than we’d like to admit.
Introduction: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca sets the stage for questions of perfection, discrimination, and dignity. This intro teases themes of human attempts to straighten what only God can set right.
Opening Thoughts
Eve started this episode with a confession—Gattaca still gives her chills. She’s seen it several times, and even knowing the ending, she gets swept up in Vincent’s desperate climb to the stars. The slow pacing that might frustrate modern audiences actually works for her, because it lets the tension simmer. Nearly three decades old, the film still feels fresh, and as Eve pointed out, what was once speculative science is edging closer to our reality.
I had a very different reaction. To be honest, Vincent made me uncomfortable from the start. If I’m going to invest in a story, I need someone I can sympathize with, and I found him unlikable. That doesn’t mean I didn’t enjoy the movie—I just latched onto other things. The retro-futurist set design with its art-deco minimalism fascinated me. I loved how the style matched the story’s themes of sterile perfection. And hey, some of my favorite actors pop up in small roles—Alan Arkin, Tony Shaloub, Ernest Borgnine. That helped me stay engaged.
One moment even made me laugh out loud. Shaloub’s character is named “German,” and the closed captions apparently decided that meant his dialogue was in German. So every time he spoke, it came up as, “In German: …” For a movie this heavy, that little glitch was priceless.
But underneath the polish, I couldn’t shake the darker undercurrents. The film never even hints at improved contraception. If everyone’s manipulating DNA, what happens to all the “unplanned” pregnancies? The implication seems to be abortion on a massive scale. And then there’s the ending, where a major character commits suicide, framed almost as a noble sacrifice once his usefulness is gone. Those unspoken dystopian notes weighed on me more than the overt conflict.
This is where Eve’s book helps frame what’s happening. Underneath the story are two key worldview layers. First, Authority: who gets to decide what perfection is? In Gattaca, it’s scientists in lab coats, dictating destiny by genetic readouts. Scripture tells us truth rests in God’s authority, not man’s consensus. Second, Presuppositions: the movie assumes that if we tinker with the blueprint long enough, we can straighten out humanity’s crookedness. But the Bible reminds us that sin—not faulty DNA—is the real problem.
So our opening reactions set the stage: Eve felt the story’s pull, I felt the unease, and both of us came face-to-face with a film that forces big questions. And those questions are where the real conversation begins.
Opening Thoughts: Screen Reader Summary
Eve was drawn into Gattaca’s suspense, while I struggled with Vincent but admired the film’s design and acting. Together, we noted the darker implications—abortion, suicide, and misplaced authority in science—and framed them through Authority and Presuppositions.
The Impossible Standard of Perfection in Gattaca
One of the central tensions in Gattaca is this so-called promise of perfection. In the film, geneticists can map out every possible trait before conception. Parents are told they can choose health, intelligence, and even appearance if they’re willing to sort through enough embryos. The story doesn’t hide the darker implication—that only the “best” embryos get implanted. The rest are discarded as not good enough. What sounded like science fiction in 1997 is now unsettlingly close to reality. Today, embryo screening and designer-baby services are not just theory but practice (see Wall Street Journal report).
For Vincent, born the old-fashioned way, the contrast is sharp. His younger brother Anton is engineered to be stronger, faster, and healthier. Vincent becomes the black sheep in his own family, not because he lacked love, but because society treated him as sickly and disposable. Gattaca doesn’t mince words—if you aren’t genetically optimized, you’re “invalid.”
Eugene, or Jerome as Vincent knows him, provides the counterpoint. He had flawless genetics. Every box checked, every trait ideal. And yet, a single accident left him disabled, no longer able to live up to the promise of his perfect profile. His worth in this society collapsed with his body. To survive, he sold his genetic identity to Vincent—ironically proving that perfection was always an illusion. We’ve talked before about science promising perfection, like in our review of Captain America: The First Avenger.
Gattaca keeps crashing into its own limits. Engineering can raise the odds, but it never erases risk. Eugene’s accident, Irene’s disqualification, and Vincent’s improbable triumph all say the same thing: no profile can make a flawless person—or a flawless life.
Humanity began perfect, reflecting God’s image in a perfect creation. But that didn’t last.
From that act of disobedience, sin corrupted creation. The problem wasn’t a missing gene; it was rebellion against God.
Every broken chromosome, every miscarriage, every accident like Eugene’s—all are symptoms of a creation still groaning under curse. That groaning can’t be solved in a laboratory.
Here is the real promise of perfection—not test tubes or embryo selection, but resurrection. God doesn’t promise us stronger DNA; He promises incorruptible bodies.
That’s what Gattaca captures, often without meaning to. Humanity was made upright, but we chased schemes. The lab technicians promise a fix for crookedness that only Christ can redeem.
Trying to engineer perfection through science is exactly that—finishing in the flesh what can only begin in the Spirit.
So where does this leave us? With Authority and Presuppositions. Gattaca assumes man has authority to define and create perfection. It presupposes that flaws are merely biological and that enough tinkering will set things right. But scripture tells us otherwise. Authority rests with God, who declared creation good, and presuppositions must start with the reality of sin. Without that lens, science promises perfection but can never deliver.
As viewers, this is where we need to pause. The allure of control is powerful. The temptation to scheme our way into an ideal future is as old as Eden. Gattaca puts that counterfeit on the screen and dares us to believe it. But the Christian response is to remember: perfection was lost in sin, regained only in Christ, and promised fully in resurrection. No genome can match that.
The Impossible Standard of Perfection in Gattaca: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca shows parents picking “perfect” embryos and discarding the rest. The film exposes society’s false hope in science to fix human crookedness. Scripture reminds us that perfection was lost in sin, not genetics, and true restoration comes only in Christ’s resurrection.
Genetic Determinism (or Prejudice) in Gattaca
In Gattaca, your destiny is decided before you take your first breath. Genetic testing sorts people into two categories: the “valid,” who are engineered for strength and intellect, and the “invalid,” who are natural-born and therefore assumed to be defective. From there, the rest of life is predetermined. Invalids are funneled into menial work, while valids are given every opportunity. It’s prejudice not by skin color or social class, but by the very code written into your DNA.
That’s what makes Vincent’s story disruptive. Growing up, he absorbed the message that he would never achieve anything. He was taught to set his sights low, and the system reinforced it every step of the way. Yet when Vincent beats his genetically superior brother Anton in a swim, the illusion cracks. Genetics may set probabilities, but they can’t define identity, character, or perseverance.
The irony is that the system’s prejudice becomes self-fulfilling. If you’re told from birth you’re inferior, you’ll often live down to that expectation. And if you’re told you’re superior, you may coast on that false security. Either way, the stereotype becomes the cage. This prejudice echoes what we saw in X-Men: Apocalypse (Part I, Part II), where genetic differences sparked fear and division.
This is where discernment comes in. Eve’s book talks about stereotypes as shortcuts in storytelling, but in Gattaca they’re elevated into law. Valids are stereotyped as capable and flawless, invalids as weak and unworthy. The Bible dismantles that entire framework.
In other words, the ground is level at the foot of the cross. No lab result or genetic profile can change that.
Genetic Determinism (or Prejudice) in Gattaca: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca divides people into “valids” and “invalids,” enforcing prejudice at the genetic level. Vincent’s defiance exposes the system’s flaws, while scripture reminds us that all are sinners, all need grace, and all are equal in Christ.
Protagonist Without Heroism
One of the subtle manipulations in Gattaca is how it frames Vincent. The film doesn’t just make him the protagonist—it works hard to make him feel like the hero. We’re meant to cheer as he bends the rules, slips past the scanners, and uses Jerome’s DNA to climb toward the stars. But sympathy for the underdog doesn’t make him admirable.
There’s an important distinction here. A protagonist is simply the character whose story drives the narrative. A hero, by contrast, is a person of noble character whose actions inspire imitation. Vincent fits the first definition perfectly. He is the central figure, the one whose choices propel the story forward. But hero? That’s a harder sell. His path is paved with deception, selfish ambition, and exploitation of Jerome’s identity. That’s not heroism—it’s fraud dressed up with a swell of music. Vincent’s false heroism reminded me of the way deception played into Spider-Man: Far From Home.
This is where Stories, as Eve describes them in her book, matter so much. Stories don’t just entertain; they teach us what to admire, what to desire, what to excuse. Gattaca tells us that authenticity means “proving your worth no matter what rules you break.” That’s secular humanism in a nutshell—self-made identity, self-made salvation. If you can game the system and make it to space, then you’ve achieved your purpose.
But biblical authenticity isn’t about ambition or rebellion. It’s about humility, truth, and service. Vincent’s lies might look noble on screen, but they collapse against scripture.
The film wants us to believe Vincent is a hero because he defies limits. But biblically, he’s just a man chasing glory at the expense of others. That’s not the kind of story Christians are called to imitate.
Protagonist Without Heroism: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca paints Vincent as a hero, but his path is built on lies and ambition. The film equates defiance with authenticity, while scripture calls us to humility, truth, and service.
Human Value and Dignity in Gattaca
One of the hardest parts of Gattaca to watch is how little value human life holds in its world. “Invalids” are treated as second-class citizens, given menial jobs and looked at as a drain on society. Even before birth, embryos that don’t meet genetic standards are simply discarded. And in the end, Eugene—once prized for his perfect genetics—chooses to end his own life, presented almost as a noble gesture once his usefulness is spent. It’s a chilling picture of dignity defined by utility. We’ve seen this utilitarian view of life before, especially with Thanos in our review of Avengers: Infinity War.
The parallels to our world are not far-fetched. Prenatal testing already gives parents the option to terminate pregnancies when genetic conditions are discovered (ABC report). In vitro fertilization allows not only for discarding embryos but even for sex selection (CCRM IVF resource). Gattaca was speculative fiction in the 90s, but in 2025 its ethical questions sit squarely in the headlines.
Eve’s book talks about Reality—and here, the film’s counterfeit reality reduces life to performance and potential. But the true reality is that life has value because God gives it value. From conception to death, every person bears His image.
These verses leave no doubt—God Himself shapes life in the womb, knows every day before it begins, and acknowledges personhood even before birth. That reality is non-negotiable, no matter how advanced our technology.
So when Gattaca portrays life as expendable, it forces us to confront a lie that our own culture is already believing. True human dignity isn’t defined by genes, usefulness, or potential—it’s defined by the Creator.
Human Value and Dignity in Gattaca: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca devalues human life through discrimination, discarded embryos, and suicide framed as noble. Scripture affirms that God forms life in the womb and grants each person dignity that technology cannot erase.
Conclusion
As we step back from Gattaca, the film feels less like speculative fiction and more like a mirror. Nearly thirty years old, it still speaks to today’s headlines—embryo selection, genetic determinism, questions of human worth. Eve and I came to it from different angles: she felt the tension of Vincent’s struggle, I wrestled with the unease of his deception. But together, we saw how the story presses big questions that Christians cannot ignore.
Through Authority, we asked who gets to define perfection. Through Presuppositions, we saw the assumption that science can fix what sin has broken. Through Stereotypes, we traced how prejudice becomes law. Through Stories, we examined Vincent’s counterfeit heroism. And through Reality, we measured the dignity of life against the Creator’s design. Every lens pointed us back to the same truth: humanity’s problem is not genetic, it’s spiritual—and Christ alone redeems it.
In the end, Gattaca challenges us not just to critique a movie but to consider the narratives shaping our culture. Do we quietly accept the lie that worth comes from ability, usefulness, or flawless DNA? Or do we stand on the reality that every human life bears God’s image? The film may offer no hope beyond human achievement, but the gospel offers incorruptible life through Christ’s resurrection. That’s the story worth living—and the one worth passing on.
Conclusion: Screen Reader Summary
Gattaca raises questions about perfection, prejudice, and dignity. Our conclusion: humanity’s problem is spiritual, not genetic, and true hope rests only in Christ’s redemption.
Global Screen Reader Summary
In this episode, we review Gattaca through a Christian worldview. We explore themes of perfection, prejudice, counterfeit heroism, and the dignity of life, using scripture and discernment principles from Eve Franklin’s Are You Just Watching? handbook. Our conclusion: science cannot fix humanity’s brokenness—only Christ offers true redemption and hope.
Please support the podcast!
Are You Just Watching? is listener supported. Special thanks to our current patrons: Isaias Santillano, Craig Hardee, Stephen Brown II, and David Lefton, for their generous support. We can't continue to share critical thinking for the entertained Christian without your financial help, so please head on over to our Patreon page and become one of our supporting patrons!
Share your feedback!
What did you think of Gattaca? We would like to know, even if just your reactions to the trailer or the topics we shared in this episode. Or what general critical-thinking and entertainment thoughts or questions do you have? Would you like to suggest a movie or TV show for us to give a Christian movie review with critical thinking?
Please connect with us
Tim
About the Author
Disciple of the Christ, husband of one, father of four, veteran of the United States Army and geek to the very core, Tim remembers some of the 1970s and and still tries to forget much of the 1980s. He spends his days working as a Cisco technician in the Hampton Roads area of Virginia and too many nights in the clutches of a good story, regardless of the delivery method.