Young Washington arrived over July 4th weekend and outperformed almost everyone's expectations, so Eve invited a guest into Tim's usual chair to make sense of it. With Tim newly relocated to Texas, Andrew Rappaport—host of the Rapp Report and of Striving for Eternity—joins Eve to review the Angel Studios telling of a young George Washington, and to ask what a Christian should do with a “based on a true story” that reshapes the history it depicts.
First Impressions of Young Washington
Eve came in a little spoiled. She had watched a few historians' reaction videos before seeing Young Washington, so she already knew the film takes liberties with the record. Her verdict anyway: it's an entertaining, well-cast movie that captures the societal tension between the British and the colonists that eventually boiled over into revolution. She was frankly surprised by how well it was doing—number two on the Fourth, number three for the weekend, beating out DC's Supergirl—especially for a small studio film she had to drive out of her way to find in a theater.
Andrew opened with his running joke that he doesn't even watch movies, but he made the case that these smaller, family-minded, patriotic films keep punching far above their budgets. He also noted how little most people actually know about Washington beyond the fictional cherry-tree story—that he served two terms, refused to be made king, and stepped down on purpose so the young republic wouldn't slide back into rule by a family. What Young Washington tries to do, Andrew said, is show not the Washington we already revere but the man who became that man.
Eve also flagged the music, as she always does. The score by Kevin, Sean, and Deana Kiner leans into colonial-era textures and turns strident and percussive in the battle scenes. For an independent film, she thought it was very well done—the kind of score you only notice is there because you'd miss it if it weren't. If you want to hear how this crew handles another Angel release, compare their conversation on The King of Kings and Eve's review of Solo Mio.
Cinematic History vs. Documentary in Young Washington
The first real theme is one Eve and Tim had already chewed on in their review of Pressure: when does a historical narrative go too far in reshaping the facts? A cinematic history makes the past interesting in a way a dry documentary rarely does, but Young Washington compresses timelines, invents a love story with a Miss Fairfax that never happened, and mashes several French commanders into one character. The film's biggest invention, both hosts noted, is the death of Washington's closest friend at Fort Necessity as a personal turning point—the man actually survived that battle and died years later of smallpox.
Andrew drew a careful line. When a filmmaker changes history for the purpose of misrepresenting it—his example was Hollywood's Noah, whose director openly wanted a different account than the Bible's—that's a real problem. When changes serve character development within a limited runtime, it's a different case, even if it's still misleading. His point for believers: every human history is recorded by fallible people with limited perspective and their own agendas. We get closer to truth by combining sources and outside evidence, but Christians have one historical narrative they can fully trust.
Eve tied it straight back to the mission of the podcast—are you just watching, absorbing whatever entertainment teaches you, or are you being entertained and then going to seek out the real history? She read the passage she had returned to the previous episode as well:
All Scripture is inspired by God and is profitable for teaching, for rebuking, for correcting, for training in righteousness, so that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work. (2 Timothy 3:16–17)
The winners write the history books, Eve reminded listeners, and even the earliest Washington biography gave us the false cherry-tree legend. Recorded history should be held with a loose hand because mankind is fallible—but the Word of God is the one history written by the all-knowing God through men, and it can be trusted completely.
Providence, Concurrence, and Superintending in Young Washington
Eve handed Andrew the doctrines he'd flagged in his notes. Providence, he explained, is the way God works through His creation to bring about His will. The movie itself frames it: a young Washington calls providence “cruel” after his father dies, then slowly comes to see God's hand at work through his failures.
Andrew distinguished two facets under that umbrella. Superintending is God working through human beings to accomplish His good—the way Paul and Moses and Luke each wrote Scripture in their own distinct style and personality, yet God gets full credit as the author. Concurrence is God using human sin and failure to bring about good. His clearest example was Joseph:
You planned evil against me; God planned it for good to bring about the present result—the survival of many people. (Genesis 50:20)
In the film, Andrew said, God uses Washington's pride and failure—pride, then the fall, then humbling—to prepare him for later responsibility. Both hosts pressed the harder edge of the doctrine: God's providence isn't only at work when things go the way we want. Eve raised the 9/11 pilot who was bumped from a doomed flight; Andrew answered with his own friend Don Peterson, who reached the airport early and boarded the earlier plane that went down in Pennsylvania. Both, they agreed, were the providence of God. Eve added the comfort she keeps returning to: no death falls outside God's sovereign timing, so a believer who survives a catastrophe need not carry survivor's guilt, and a believer who grieves a young death can trust it was not outside God's will. Andrew warned this is exactly where the word-of-faith movement does damage—telling the sick or the grieving they simply lacked enough faith.
Wisdom, Failure, and the Discipline of God
Washington's mother tells him that failure is the tutor that makes a man wise. Eve pushed gently on that. She turned to the passage she says comes to mind first whenever wisdom is the subject:
Now if any of you lacks wisdom, he should ask God—who gives to all generously and ungrudgingly—and it will be given to him. But let him ask in faith without doubting. For the doubter is like the surging sea, driven and tossed by the wind. That person should not expect to receive anything from the Lord, being double-minded and unstable in all his ways. (James 1:5–8)
Eve's distinction: it isn't failure itself that produces wisdom so much as discipline. God disciplines His children to keep them on the right path, and we gain wisdom through that discipline rather than through failure alone. Andrew agreed that's one means of wisdom, and added that the deeper struggle for most people is discerning God's will—treating it as some hidden thing to be found. God gives wisdom generously so we can examine Scripture and make the best decision in front of us, exactly as Washington had to when he thought he was finished with the army and chose to return. Andrew lingered on one word Eve had read: ungrudgingly. God gives wisdom generously and without criticizing you for needing to ask. Eve added the follow-up: ask in faith, without the self-doubt that second-guesses the very guidance you asked for. She closed the theme with two more proverbs:
When a mocker is punished, the inexperienced become wiser; when one teaches a wise man, he acquires knowledge. (Proverbs 21:11)
Instruct the wise, and he will be wiser still; teach the righteous, and he will learn more. (Proverbs 9:9)
Pride Goes Before the Fall
Eve pointed out that Washington isn't the only proud man in Young Washington—the British officers are arrogant, some of them stupidly so. His own great mistake is Fort Necessity: he chooses bad ground, refuses counsel to move, and holds his position until he's besieged and forced to surrender. In one striking beat, a British officer refuses Washington's orders because his own commission is royal—and is promptly shot off his horse. Pride, quite literally, came before the fall.
Pride comes before destruction and an arrogant spirit before a fall. (Proverbs 16:18)
General Braddock, Eve noted, is probably the most historical example—marching his men into French territory the way he'd always fought, ignoring Washington's warnings, and getting himself and his soldiers cut down. Against all that arrogance, Eve set the humility Washington eventually learns:
When arrogance comes, disgrace follows, but with humility comes wisdom. (Proverbs 11:2)
Do nothing out of selfish ambition or conceit, but in humility consider others as more important than yourselves. Everyone should look not to his own interests, but rather to the interests of others. (Philippians 2:3–4)
That last verse, Eve argued, is what plays out at the film's end. When Washington rejoins the militia he takes no rank; he comes back as an advisor to make it up to his men and keep them safe, then risks his life to rescue them. Taking command of the Virginia militia, he tells everyone he is neither an officer nor a gentleman but a Virginian—putting himself on the same level as the men he leads. It's the humility, both hosts observed, that history suggests he carried into the Revolution and the presidency: no crown, self-imposed term limits, a man who had learned not to chase the empty accolades of the British war machine.
Endurance and a New Kind of Battlefield
Andrew drew out one more thread—endurance. A line in the film calls failure “the tutor sent by God,” and after his fall Washington doesn't quit; he recognizes the discipline as providence and keeps going, stepping into a new world of frontier warfare that the old European way of fighting couldn't handle. Andrew turned that into a challenge for the church: too much of our apologetics still defends the faith to a 1950s culture that knew the Bible, instead of the confused, largely biblically illiterate culture in front of us now.
Pointing to Paul—who reasoned differently with synagogue Jews than with the pagans at Mars Hill—and to Ken Ham's work at Answers in Genesis, Andrew argued that reaching people today means starting further back, at creation, rather than assuming a shared starting point that no longer exists. Eve agreed: the United States is now a mission field, full of people whose only exposure to Jesus is His name used as a curse—which, she suggested, is itself a teaching opportunity rather than only an offense.
The Most Important Message
Andrew paused the movie talk to share what he called the most important thing either host could say. You and I, he said, break God's law; we carry the same pride Washington had. God is infinitely holy, just, and loving—and because His holiness is infinite, sin against Him carries infinite consequence. We would stand guilty in His sight and deserve the second death.
But God made a way of escape. God Himself came as a man, Jesus Christ, who never broke God's law and, as an eternal being, could pay an eternal penalty in our place at the cross. That, Andrew said, is what sets Christianity apart from every man-made religion of doing enough good to earn heaven: Jesus did it all. He urged any listener who hasn't gotten right with God to turn from sin and trust solely in what Jesus did on the cross—not faith plus works—and to reach out to Eve, who would gladly send along a study Bible. Eve pointed listeners to feedback@AreYouJustWatching.com to do exactly that.
Takeaways
- Young Washington is an entertaining, well-scored Angel Studios film that takes real liberties with history—compressed timelines, an invented romance, a friend's fictional battlefield death—so enjoy it, then go read the actual record.
- All human history is recorded by fallible people; Scripture is the one fully trustworthy account, God-breathed and profitable (2 Timothy 3:16–17).
- Providence is God working through His creation; superintending is God working good through people, and concurrence is God using even human sin and failure for good (Genesis 50:20).
- God's providence is at work in loss as much as in rescue—a truth that frees believers from survivor's guilt and guards against the word-of-faith error of blaming the suffering for weak faith.
- Wisdom is asked for in faith and given generously and ungrudgingly (James 1:5–8); God often grows it through discipline, not merely through failure.
- Pride precedes the fall, and humility precedes wisdom (Proverbs 16:18; 11:2; Philippians 2:3–4)—the arc Washington walks from Fort Necessity to “I am a Virginian.”
- The gospel is the point: Christ kept the law we broke and paid the penalty we owed, and He calls us to turn and trust in Him alone.
Discernment Rubric
A quick guide for watching Young Washington thoughtfully, drawn from the conversation:
- Truth vs. entertainment: Does the film present itself as history, and where does it reshape the record? Name the invented beats (the romance, the friend's death, the composite Frenchman) before letting the movie teach you “history.”
- Worldview of providence: The film gestures at God's protection and providence. Test it against Scripture—God is sovereign over both rescue and loss, not only the outcomes we prefer.
- Character & virtue: Watch the pride-to-humility arc. Which characters are humbled, which are destroyed by arrogance, and what does that reveal about wisdom?
- Gospel clarity: The movie is not a Christian film and doesn't preach the gospel—so bring it. Use Washington's failures and humbling as a springboard to the substitute who bore our failure.
- Talk it out: After the credits, ask your family what was true, what was invented, and where God's Word corrects the film's assumptions.
Where to watch Young Washington
Please support the podcast!
Are You Just Watching? is listener supported. Special thanks to our current patrons: Isaias Santillano, Stephen Brown II, and David Lefton, for their generous support. We can't continue to share critical thinking for the entertained Christian without your financial help, so please head on over to our Patreon page and become one of our supporting patrons!
Prefer a one-time gift? You can also leave us a tip on Ko-fi — every bit helps keep the show going!
Share your feedback!
What did you think of Young Washington? We would like to know, even if just your reactions to the trailer or the topics we shared in this episode. Or what general critical-thinking and entertainment thoughts or questions do you have? Would you like to suggest a movie or TV show for us to give a Christian movie review with critical thinking?
- Comment on the shownotes
- Call (513) 818-2959 to leave a voicemail
- Email feedback@AreYouJustWatching.com (audio files welcome)
- Join our Facebook discussion group.
